SC Allows One-Time Karthigai Deepam at Thiruparankundram

Must Read

For nearly a year, an extraordinary constitutional spectacle has played out over a single sacred lamp on Thiruparankundram Hill in Madurai. On November 20, 2026, a Supreme Court bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi finally granted interim relief, permitting a limited team from the Arulmigu Subramaniya Swamy Temple to light the traditional Karthigai Deepam atop the ancient Deepathoon (stone lamp pillar) on November 24.

​While devotees across Tamil Nadu celebrate this overdue reprieve ahead of Karthigai Deepam, the legal battle that preceded it exposes a far deeper malaise: how state machinery, bureaucratic jargon, and the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) department routinely collude to deny Hindus basic ritual rights at their own sacred sites.

- Advertisement -

​The Curious Case of the Shifting Excuses

​Thiruparankundram is no ordinary hillock. Revered in Sangam literature and Tamil devotional tradition as the first of Lord Murugan’s six sacred abodes (Arupadai Veedu), the hill has been a center of continuous Hindu worship for centuries. Yet, when devotees sought to restore the traditional lighting of the Karthigai Deepam at the Deepathoon situated on the lower peak of the temple hill, they were met not by religious dialogue, but by a wall of state-sponsored obstruction.

​What makes the Tamil Nadu government’s legal posture particularly revealing is how rapidly its excuses mutated whenever one argument collapsed in court:

- Advertisement -

​1. First, the “Jain Structure” Claim: In December 2025, the state-controlled temple administration told the Madras High Court that the stone pillar was actually a Jain monument—an argument that conveniently ignored centuries of Shaivite-Kaumara continuity on the hill.

​2. Next, the “British Survey Stone” Theory: When the archaeological deflection failed to convince the High Court, the state pivoted to colonial bureaucracy. Appearing before the Supreme Court, state counsel argued that the Deepathoon was merely a British-era survey marker, warning the judges that allowing lamps there would somehow turn “thousands of survey pillars” across Tamil Nadu into religious shrines. As counsel for the worshippers pointed out in court, basic visual inspection dismantled that claim: colonial survey stones do not feature carved depressions specifically designed to hold oil and wicks.

- Advertisement -

​3. Finally, the “Imaginary Ghost” of Law and Order: Alongside the Dargah management—which claimed ownership over a pillar located nearly 200 meters away from the Hazrat Sultan Sikandar Badusha Dargah on a separate peak—the administration repeatedly invoked fears of public disorder.

​In January 2026, a Division Bench of the Madras High Court saw straight through this administrative theater, dismissing the state’s law-and-order fears as an “imaginary ghost” and affirming that the Deepathoon stood squarely on temple land.

​Weaponizing Section 163 Against the Judiciary

​Even more troubling than the historical revisionism was the executive’s open defiance of judicial authority. When Justice G.R. Swaminathan originally allowed the writ petition in December 2025, district authorities promptly slapped prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) to block devotees from complying with the High Court’s directive.

​Justice Swaminathan’s warning at the time—that allowing executive officers to nullify court orders through manufactured prohibitory clamps would lead to “anarchy”—struck at the heart of a recurring pattern across India. Whenever a radical street veto or minority appeasement calculus threatens to clash with a Hindu religious practice, the state reflexively surrenders to intimidation, restricts the peaceful worshipper, and cites “public peace” as its alibi. Whether under the previous DMK regime or the current TVK dispensation in Chennai, the bureaucratic instinct remained identical: fight the devotee all the way to New Delhi.

​The HR&CE Paradox: Who Speaks for the Temple?

​Perhaps the sharpest indictment in the Thiruparankundram saga falls upon the HR&CE department itself. Created ostensibly to administer Hindu temples and protect their traditions, the department stood shoulder-to-shoulder with the Dargah committee in opposing the lighting of a sacred lamp at Lord Murugan’s abode.

​As one petitioner’s counsel poignantly asked the Supreme Court: “How is anyone affected by just lighting this lamp for two hours, one day a year?”

​There is no rational answer to that question—because the objection was never about inconvenience, safety, or archaeology. It was about asserting dominance over sacred geography and testing how easily Hindu religious rights can be erased behind secular paperwork.

​A Temporary Light, A Permanent Lesson

​The Supreme Court’s interim order ensures that the Karthigai flame will burn atop the Deepathoon on November 24. However, because the Apex Court has stayed the broader findings of the Madras High Court pending final adjudication, the underlying constitutional battle is far from over.

​Thiruparankundram is a wake-up call. As long as Hindu temples remain under state control, their custodians will continue to treat ancient Deepathoons as colonial survey stones—and devotees will be forced to knock on the doors of the Supreme Court simply to light a lamp in their own sanctum.

- Advertisement -

More articles

- Advertisement -

Latest Article